Empowering Businesses with Innovative Solar Solutions

From Whale Oil to Kerosene to Advanced Black Pellets: Lessons in Energy Transition Across Two Centuries

Kevin Gallant, P. Eng.FEC Oct 2025

Doing some recent research for my new book title “Belt When Broken”… The story is based in the 1870s when steam and railroad dominated the landscape from Ferries to Trains.   There were some new fuels and during my research it was evident that buildings required a lot of coal to maintain heat and comfort for the Mechanic Institutes in Saint John for example. This is s time decades before universities were established.   Lights in the 1800s consisted of candles and oil lamps but soon replaced by a new fuel Kerosene.   What really surprise me at the provincial archives was the number of patents during the 1850s.  I attached part of the list and a briefing from the Ottis Logue , PEng. collection at the provincial archives. Two highlights for me we that A Gesner not only invented Kerosene but Asphalt.  It took quite awhile for roads to add asphalt but demonstrate the innovative 200 years. Ago.

---

Comparative Analysis of Fuel Transitions: Kerosene (1854) and Advanced Black Pellets (2025)

A Social Acceptance and Historical Lessons Report

Energy transitions redefine daily life, economic structure, and cultural expectations. In 1854, kerosene disrupted an entrenched whale-oil-based energy economy and transformed household lighting and industry. In 2025, advanced black pellets—engineered biomass fuels—represent another potential shift, driven primarily by the need to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and transition away from fossil fuel dependency.
This report examines how society accepted kerosene in the mid-19th century and compares it to the challenges facing modern adoption of advanced black pellet fuels, with a focus on social attitudes, sacrifices made, and lessons that remain relevant today.

---

The Pre-Kerosene Era: Whale Oil as a Dominant Fuel

Prior to kerosene’s introduction, whale oil was a central illuminant and a critical component of maritime and coastal economies.

2.1 Whale Oil Use Cases (c. 1700–1850)

Use Case	Description	Social Role
Household Lighting	Whale oil lamps provided a steady, low-flicker flame.	Symbol of status — high-quality light indicated wealth.
Street Lamps in Cities	Whale oil lanterns illuminated public streets and docks.	Supported expanding urban life after dark.
Industrial Lubrication	Whale oil used in textile mills, machine gears, and clocks.	Enabled early industrial mechanization.
Pharmaceuticals and Soaps	Refined whale oil used in salves, candles, and soaps.	Integrated into daily hygiene and medical culture.
Maritime Economy	Whaling supported port towns, shipbuilding, ropeworks, cooperages.	Entire communities and identities tied to the industry.

Whale oil was more than a fuel—it was embedded in identity, livelihood, and national expansion narratives. This meant replacing it required not only new technology, but cultural adaptation.

---

3. Emergence of Kerosene (1854): Innovation and Public Acceptance

Kerosene rapidly entered the market in the 1850s as an affordable and bright lighting fuel. Its adoption was not automatic; it required trade-offs and significant cultural change.

3.1 Advantages Driving Acceptance

• Brighter, clearer light than whale oil or tallow candles.
• Lower and more stable prices, especially after petroleum refining scaled.
• Consistent supply, unlike whale populations, which were declining.

3.2 Sacrifices and Social Adjustments

Area of Sacrifice	Description
Safety Concerns	Early kerosene lamps were prone to fire and explosion; households accepted new daily hazards.
Occupational Displacement	Whaling towns faced unemployment, cultural loss, and economic decline.
Skill Adaptation	Families learned to trim wicks, store flammable fuel, and maintain metal lamps.

Kerosene succeeded because its benefits were immediate—people saw and felt the improvement in household lighting.

---

4. Advanced Black Pellets (2025): A Modern Low-Carbon Fuel Transition

Advanced black pellets are processed biomass fuels designed to replace coal and heating oil in boilers, district heating, and industrial systems. They burn more efficiently than raw wood and can be transported and stored like coal.

4.1 Drivers for Adoption

• Pressure to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
• Declining social tolerance for fossil-fuel pollution.
• Economic incentives for “drop-in” alternatives in existing combustion systems.

4.2 Social Barriers to Acceptance

Unlike kerosene, the benefits of black pellets are not immediately visible to households.

Challenge	Impact
Benefits Are Collective and Long-Term	Climate benefits accrue globally, not inside a household.
Upfront System Cost	Boilers and furnaces may require conversion or replacement.
Cultural Resistance	Fossil fuels are deeply tied to modern identity and political narratives.
Regional Job Impacts	Energy transition threatens communities tied to coal, oil, and gas, similar to whaling towns in the 1850s.

Modern society expects high safety, low inconvenience, and predictable cost, making behavioral change more difficult.

---

5. Comparative Social Acceptance Lessons

Lesson	1854 Transition to Kerosene	2025 Transition to Black Pellets
Motivation for Change	Brighter light, better daily life.	Climate mitigation and policy compliance.
Personal Benefit Visibility	Immediate and tangible.	Diffuse and long-term.
Economic Disruption	Whaling towns declined; refinery economies rose.	Coal/oil regions may decline; biomass supply chains rise.
Risk Tolerance	Households accepted fire/explosion hazard.	Modern populations demand near-zero risk.

Key Insight:
Kerosene succeeded because the benefit was personal and visible.
Modern fuels succeed only when collective benefits are translated into personal advantages (cost savings, convenience, reliability, identity alignment).

---

The transition from whale oil to kerosene demonstrates that societies will adopt new fuels when they clearly improve daily life, even if the transition requires risk and economic upheaval. In contrast, the shift to low-carbon fuels today occurs in a world where benefits are more abstract, costs are more visible, and cultural identity is more entrenched.

To enable widespread acceptance of advanced black pellets, policy and industry strategies must make benefits:

• Immediate (e.g., lower heating bills)
• Visible (air quality improvements, local job creation)
• Culturally positive (“modern, responsible heating,” not sacrifice-driven)

Only when the transition feels like progress, not loss, will society embrace it as readily as it once embraced kerosene. Below is the archival reference to Dr. Abraham Gesner on Energy by Ottis Logue.

Partial Patent List